•  
  •  
 

Abstract

This response to “'Not Just Boring Adult Stuff': Issue-Based and Critical Pedagogies for Civic and Political Learning in Welsh Primary Classrooms" acknowledges the article’s valuable contribution in showing that young children can participate meaningfully in civic education. However, it challenges two central claims: that teachers in Wales require greater professional autonomy to enact inquiry-based civic learning, and that inspection and assessment arrangements operate as structural barriers to such practice. Although recent curriculum reforms have afforded teachers increased autonomy and opportunities for creativity, this has not necessarily improved teaching quality or strengthened curriculum coherence, issues that disproportionately affect disadvantaged learners. Moreover, the argument that inspection and assessment pressures constrain civic inquiry is unconvincing; the inspectorate actively promotes critical thinking, values innovative pedagogy, and encourages community engagement, while primary schools retain significant control over assessment arrangements. This paper maintains that the central challenges, therefore, are not excessive external accountability but variable teaching quality and vague curriculum expectations. It agrees with the author that sustained professional learning is needed to support teachers in realizing the curriculum’s democratic and pedagogical ambitions.

Included in

Education Commons

Share

COinS