Abstract
In “Why We Should Keep the Discussion Going: Agonism, Deliberative Democracy, and Democratic Education,” the authors dismiss earlier claims that agonistic and deliberative democracy are irreconcilable. They propose a method for teaching that merges the two theories, called "agonistic deliberative scenarios," which centers on ethical dilemmas and controversial topics. This response discusses three issues brought to the fore by the article, in which the proposed method risks steering away from agonistic democracy. The three topics relate to the roles of hegemony, ethics, and controversial issues to democratic education. The response takes as its starting point the notion that attempts to unite agonistic and deliberative democratic education are difficult, as they stem from differing ideas of what constitutes democratic practice.
Recommended Citation
Tysklind, E. N.
(2026).
What Is This Democracy We Are Teaching For? A Response to “Why We Should Keep the Discussion Going: Agonism, Deliberative Democracy, and Democratic Education”.
Democracy & Education,
34
(2), Article 4.
Available at:https://doi.org/10.65214/2164-7992.1831