Abstract
In this study, I examine how some U.S. secondary social studies teachers understand and teach about the concept of democracy during a period of political polarization and concern about democratic norms. I use qualitative interviews with 16 social studies teachers from different regions and school settings across the United States. Using the existing literature about democracy in education, I created a framework that groups teachers’ views into four categories: Technical Democracy, Lived Democracy, Historical Democracy, and A-Democratic. A fifth theme, Contested Democracy, also emerged from the data. Many teachers described democracy in technical terms and focused on institutions, procedures, and structures of government. Others emphasized participation, historical context, or critical discussion. Some participants questioned whether the United States fully reflects democratic ideals. Several also reported limits on classroom discussion due to institutional pressures or concerns about controversy. These findings suggest that teachers’ approaches to democracy reflect both their own beliefs and the broader political climate. The study points to the need for support in curriculum, teacher preparation, and policy to help educators address democratic issues in challenging contexts.
Recommended Citation
Hornbeck, D.
(2026).
Teaching Democracy When Democracy Is Contested: U.S. Social Studies Teacher Perspectives.
Democracy & Education,
34
(2), Article 2.
Available at:https://doi.org/10.65214/2164-7992.1779