•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Future-proofing democratic education in today's polarized political climate requires developing new strategies to foster mutual respect and understanding in classrooms amid frequent disagreements. Recently, however, some scholars working within democratic education have suggested that, given irreconcilable differences, agonistic pluralists should cease engaging with deliberative theorists altogether. This paper, written collaboratively by authors from both traditions, offers a rebuttal to this view. We argue that, specifically in democratic education, agonists and deliberative democrats are valuable conversation partners because both theories emphasize the discursive aspects of democracy, the pluralistic nature of societies, and the dangers of unmitigated political conflict. While the ontological differences between the traditions are real and the points of contention are valid, this does not prevent valuable insights from emerging in the discussion—especially when the conversation focuses more on the practical than the theoretical. Accordingly, we argue that certain educational practices are beneficial across both theoretical traditions, thereby strengthening the case for their desirability. Calling our approach agonistic deliberative scenarios, we suggest that such practices should combine methods such as structured academic controversy with scenario-based learning activities that incorporate elements of case studies, role-taking, conversation, and debate.

Share

COinS